Transcript 0:01 [rock music] All right, good afternoon, happy Wednesday. 0:34 Thanks for watching on The Osceola's YouTube channel. This is Seminole Sidelines. Jerry Cutts, Osceola publisher, joining me. I'm Bob Ferrante, The Osceola's editor. 0:44 We're gonna do similar to last Wednesday, a little bit of a break from the football discussion, because Ross Dellinger has gifted us quite the discussion topic mid-football season. 0:56 It's not a, it's not a realignment story. 0:58 This is not full on, uh, the Pac-12 is trying to make a comeback, but this is a really interesting, um, revenue structure proposal that has been, um, clearly close enough to being floated for somebody to leak it to Ross Dellinger, and for him to put it out on Yahoo Sports Tuesday night. 1:19 Again, Yahoo is a partner of Rivals. The Osceola, part of that Rivals network, so we appreciate Ross's, uh, dogged reporting a- as we, um, we've enjoyed digging into these business of college athletic stories. 1:33 Jerry, I'm not sure I expected this kind of story to happen mid-September, but this feels like an interesting proposal. 1:41 I've called it an olive branch without knowing how strong of an olive branch it is between the ACC and Florida State and Clemson. 1:50 Um, before we kind of dig into the bullet points, your initial thoughts, I guess, as you read this story from Ross. Well, my first thought is mediation is working. 2:02 You know, the threat of a lawsuit has got people's attention, and, uh, you know, there's two types of mediation. One is what goes on that's driven by the courts, and, uh, 2:18 you know, and John Cooper has, you know, encouraged that, as he always does. 2:24 But the other type of mediation is ongoing, and, you know, Michael Alford had told me that there's hardly a day that passes that he and Jim Phillips don't speak, and, and oftentimes about, 2:41 you know, matters pertaining to how to solve this problem. And as Alford has said since day one, and repeatedly, is this isn't a question of relationships, it's a question of math. So, um, 2:59 you know, Alford has never said, "Our goal is to get out of the ACC." Uh, what he said is, "Our goal is to, uh, 3:11 you know, find a way to be able to compete with the Big Ten and the SEC who are gonna generate..." Ev- the number I've always heard is 40 million or more a year- Good number... than any other conference. 3:27 It was interesting to me, as I noted to you, Bob, when I read Dellinger used the number 30 million or more, and, uh, I, I haven't seen that number, 3:38 so I don't know what that means, and that's a good conversation for us to have with Dellinger or text to him. I don't think it was a typo. That, that isn't, you know, something I've seen from him. 3:52 So, you know, hats off to him. He's doing a great job of reporting. You know, he's got a good source, for sure. Yeah, this is a, a complex story and, and I'll be, I'll be straight with you. 4:04 Read it once last night, edited it, got it on the site. Sure. It's been a good discussion topic on The Osceola Village. 4:11 Went ahead and, and read it again, trying to make sure I, I, I've retained a lot of the interesting talking points. Um, still pretty complex. I still have my, my healthy skepticism here. Oh, yeah. 4:22 But I, I think it's encouraging. And, and listen, Dellinger, De- Dellinger, I mean, he, he repeated himself three or four times saying that this is, you know, very preliminary and, uh, 4:36 it's gonna be difficult to get, you know, the kit- the kittens herded together and to get a two-thirds vote. So, you know, we may be a ways before this is, uh, you know, 4:53 uh, more formulated. But, uh, um, you know, it's encouraging. It's encouraging to see that the presidents are having meetings and talking about it. 5:05 I agree, and it's- And that's what the purpose of the, that's what the purpose of the lawsuit was. I mean, FSU was getting nowhere before bringing the lawsuit, and 10 short months later they're having meetings? 5:19 I think that speaks productively. And I, I think Florida State and Clemson have been proactive. Uh, again, Florida State and Clemson can't be in a collusion sense as far as the lawsuit. 5:34 There are separate lawsuits in separate states. I'm not going there particularly. Yeah. 5:39 But the reason why these success initiatives, that hot word that came about, um, let's say 18 months ago or so in Amelia Island, success initiatives are here because Florida State and Clemson 5:54 talked through what are some options. What's a partial bridge? What's a small solution to get to a number? 6:01 And, and I think Michael Alford, Florida State's athletic director, uh, Graham Neff, Clemson's athletic director, talk a lot. And, and they have put together what, what are some ideas? Let- let's put our heads together. 6:13 Let's, let's brainstorm possibilities. Um, I think Success Initiatives was a massive step. It was announced in May of 2023. 6:22 We didn't really know much about it until, honestly, some of your reporting, some reporting by the Associated Press, maybe a couple weeks ago as far as what it really looked like. 6:33 So I just wanna tell people these things develop very, very, uh, slowly, gradually with these meetings, where it's tough to get presidents and chancellors either together in a room in Charlotte or on a, on a Zoom or on a phone call. 6:48 But to me, Jerry, this is similar, a- again, similar, uh, to the Success Initiatives. Do you, do you agree with that, and what, what are your thoughts? Yeah. Yeah, I agree with that. 7:01 And what, you know, Michael Alford said in that interview that we did with him, it took 18 months to get the presidents for Jim, you know, for Jim Phillips, the commissioner, to get enough of the presidents to agree on this Success Initiative. 7:19 You know, 18 months it took. So maybe it's easier the second time around with this initiative, but, uh, 7:32 but you know, it's, it's no small feat to get 18 people at your church, you know, a committee meeting to agree, or your neighborhood homeowners association meeting to agree. Uh, we have... 7:47 We've all been there and done that, and it's so... Yeah, but I, I, I think if, in my opinion, if you concede to one, you might, you might be more inclined to concede to a second. And, um, 8:06 so I mean, some people may dig their heels in and say, "Well, listen, we've already conceded to one. That's all." But I, I don't know. It, it's a shot. And, uh, I think if the teams want to keep the league together, 8:23 that, that they'd be inclined to do this. It, it takes progressive thinking, and I think there's a lot of progressive thinkers in college athletics, you know, whether you're an AD or an administrator. 8:37 Um, presidents and chancellors have to get, um, kind of wrap their head around what this can mean short term, what this can mean long term. 8:46 I, I think, uh, you know, I saw on, on Twitter, uh, the, the story broke Tuesday night. There was a lot of, uh, commentary from folks in Big 12 country saying, "We've seen this movie before with Texas." 8:57 You know- Right... this did work in the short term for Texas until the Longhorns saw that grant of rights with, with the conference going down, I think it was two years, and then they said, "Hey, that's great. 9:09 We're jumping in the SEC." This is a different grant of rights. It's a different structure with, with what we're looking at, uh, with the ACC. I, I think I'm- This-... 9:19 I'm curious, Jerry, when we look at this, this massive revenue gap too, it, it could be, as you said, 30 million, 40 million. I believe the ACC structure is locked in at a 4 or 4.5% escalator annually. 9:34 So that's not a lot. That's okay when you look back at, at when and where it was signed, but comparable to the current market, comparable to- Right... these newer contracts, SEC and Big Ten. 9:48 Um, it, it's only going to escalate out of control. Is it, is it feasible? It... Can you imagine 9:57 a Wake Forest athletic director, a Syracuse athletic director, a, a chancellor at, at a school in a lesser position saying, "We need to do this. We need to be progressive"? And how do you sell it? Yeah. 10:10 I, I think you look... I think you have to look back at history, and I think Stanford and Cal can remind people. If, if you look at the, at the Pac-12, um, at one time they had an uneven revenue structure with, uh, 10:28 uh, USC and UCLA made more money than the rest of the conference made. And when they entered into the... It was Pac-10, I think, at that time. 10:38 And then when they went into the new contract, that got deleted out, that it would be an even revenue share. And USC went on record, I've read, that immediately, that as soon as that contract was over, they were out, 10:55 and to the word, they were. And, you know, I don't know where Cal stands on that. They've sued UCLA to, you know, and are receiving revenue from that, UCLA's departure. 11:14 But they may have a memory of that that says, "We would've been better, you know, taking an uneven distribution, less than USC and UCLA. 11:26 In the long haul, we would've been better to have taken the, the smaller distribution and kept the conference together." You know? Right. S- so depending on how those two schools feel, uh, you know, they could swing the, 11:45 swing the vote one way or the other. Let... Bob, I think we ought to stop a second and back up and let our readers know what all i- is in that proposal. Um, it, it... 12:03 There's, there's a couple parts to it. One of which is also a, a negotiation of shortening the len- length of the, uh, grant of rights. Right. And th- that one is 12:18 I think also of a lot of importance to our readers, and what we know about it at this point is limited. Because I would imagine to shorten the length of that, it wouldn't be just a ACC decision. 12:36 I would think there'd have to be some agreement from ESPN in that as well. Right? That's the inner pound gorilla, is we still don't know ESPN's line of thinking- Right... here in, in the future of the conference, right? 12:51 Yeah. So if the conference wants to keep Florida State and Clemson in the ACC, and taking a few years off of that grant of rights is, is one way to do it. 13:09 You know, would they be willing to do that? 13:13 Understanding that they wanted the, the term to be long to help recover the investment they made in the ACC network, which is now generating significant money a year for each school. So, 13:33 you know, they've got a return on investment calculation, and how, how many years would they be willing to take off that grant of rights? So there's a couple of... 13:43 It's an interesting topic with a lot of, uh, question marks. I think with a lot of these, these stories we have more questions that come out than, than actual answers- Yeah... until you actually see the, 13:57 the fine print, the proposal of, of a fine print. And, and part of this proposal, you know, is I think Ross says it's, it's two separate pot of revenue to be divided based on your media value metrics. 14:12 You know, I'll put those, I'll emphasize those 'cause he, he used those exact words, "To be divided based on media value metrics." I think I know what that means. I think that means eyeballs watching football games. 14:26 Yeah. I think that means eyeballs watching Duke or North Carolina basketball games. I... What, what can that... A- am I missing anything else? Like, if we were listing, what, what are we talking about, Jerry? 14:39 What do you think? Well, if you remember Alford's presentation to the board of trustees, what, two years ago now, or come January? I think it was January of '22 or January '23. 14:55 He, he, he presented a chart showing that when you divide revenue equally with 14 or 15 members, Florida State gets about 7% of the media revenue. 15:12 But then he put a chart up and showed that each Clemson and Florida State are generating 14% of the eyeballs, right? Right. And then 15:28 number three is down s- you know, significantly beneath what Florida State and, and Clemson are, are generating. 15:40 And that was Florida State's initial proposal to the ACC, was to use some media metric, and that got shut down. 15:51 And, and then Florida State pursued, and Clemson, a success initiative, which had legs 'cause that... You know, let, let, let's face it. In terms of, um, 16:10 media brand, y- Florida State and Clemson have a, they have a brand established that is getting eyeballs. For 16:27 Miami or North Carolina or e- the, the, the lesser of the ACC teams to really impact what their, their media, the eyeballs they get is h- is harder. 16:45 I mean, Miami this year's gonna have a lot of eyeballs. So- Right... you know, they'll, they'll make the case 16:53 probably through, as the course of this year, they're gonna get a higher percent of, a, a percentage of eyeballs this year maybe than Florida State will, right? So success will help them in that metric. Um, 17:12 but, uh, you know, I think that's the issue I would have if I was Boston College or Wake or one of them, is... I mean, we're so f- they, they are so far down in terms of the percentage of eyeballs that they're getting 17:29 that it's kind of a losing hand they're dealt. There's not a lot o- of opportunity to make money for them on this metric. Whereas with the success initiative, there is. 17:45 I mean, if they make the top, finish in the top 25, get a bowl game, you know, they, it's, that's $5.5 million in their pocket. That's attainable, right? 17:58 Now, if they win the ACC championship, which there's been, what, four or five teams win the ACC championship here in the past 10 years. Yeah. I mean, beyond Clemson, Florida State, Pitt had their great year. Yeah. Yeah. 18:15 There are some opportunities aside from the Florida State and Clemson mix. So if you were to win the AC championship, one of those teams, downline teams, 18:26 in the year Pitt won the, the Nash- I mean, the, uh, ACC championship, they would get the automatic berth, and they'd get an extra four million. 18:35 So in that year, they could make eight or nine million on the ACC initiative, and that's within their control. You know, you can do that. Um, I think the eyeballs, I, I'd be curious to see how much, 18:53 how far you can move the needle when you're having a great year, like Miami is gonna maybe have this year, if, if they can continue to win. Um, how will their eyeballs move 19:10 up, uh, compared to their normal year? A- and there's another big factor there that Andy Miller, you know, points out to me on the regular when we're on this conversation. A lot of the reason your eyeballs, 19:26 the ACC's eyeballs are not as good as SEC numbers or Big Ten numbers- Right... is the time slots they put the ACC in, right? Yep. 19:39 I mean, if you, if you put SEC games in the top time slots, well, they're gonna get more eyeballs, not because of who they are, but, but because of when they're playing. And, and so, 19:56 you know, again, if I'm Boston College from Syracuse, I'm going, "Well, heck, are you gonna put me in the good time slots, or are you gonna keep putting me in at noon?" I mean, those are discussions. 20:10 Yeah, I'm, I'm comfortable saying that Florida State/Cal is the 7:00 ESPN2 game. It, it doesn't feel like that... Like, that's a good slot, for example. Yeah, yeah. 20:18 But, but Florida State's not going to be in that slot if, if losses pile up, and, and the league's gonna have to find good games to fill good slots. I think maybe that that is in the 7:30 slot because of Cal. Sure. 20:32 But not, not just because they're 3-0, but they want that West Coast audience. Oh, agreed. And it's their first game in the ACC. So if you play at 7:30, that, that means my son will be watching it in Berkeley at 4:30, 20:51 right, in his sports bar there in, in the Bay Area. So I think you'll start to see those kind of match-ups in, in later time slots. It does. It makes a lot of sense. 21:06 Um, you know, one of the things we touched on earlier is, is a lot of these 21:11 rules, whatever we want to call them, ACC guidelines, uh, the success initiatives, that took a two-third, uh, majority vote of the presidents and chancellors at each of the schools around the league. 21:24 Again, I'll emphasize, Jim Phillips is a consensus builder. He tries to listen. He tries to bring people to the table. He tries to build consensus. Right. Here's the, here's the 30 or $40 million question. [laughs] It... 21:38 Next year, every school is going to be looking for an additional 20 to 25 million potentially if this House/NCAA settlement comes through. Yeah. It's gonna be a line on your athletic department ledger. 21:53 You got to figure it out. Um, I, I believe in the board of trustees meeting, they called it a cap, although it, it can slightly, I believe, escalate in, in future years. 22:03 So it's a little bit of a step type of deal, but this is a massive number that every, again, president, chancellor, AD, board of trustees, they're trying to figure all this stuff out. Are, 22:16 are other schools going to be willing to give up future money to potentially appease Florida State/Clemson? 22:24 Or is this just, "Hey, we've got to do this if we're a smaller school," a Wake, a Boston College, whatnot, "because that's, that's collectively what we think is good for our future as well as the conference"? 22:36 It- it's a massive question. Yeah. Uh, Jerry, I just don't... How, how do you get that two-third majority vote? It's gonna be tough with some of those, um, schools. 22:51 I mean, if you're running the athletic budget at a school that's $100 million, um, and you have to come up with 22.5 million more, it's a whole different conversation 23:07 than if you're at a school with $200 million athletic budget. You know? Yeah. Just... And, and what's your ability to generate revenue? Like at Florida State, we've had great success over the years generating 23:24 revenue through our booster organization. It's been one of the more successful in the country. Um, but not every school has a booster organization like that. It's gonna depend on who is sitting in the president's chair. 23:43 Is the president willing to lower athletic fees to help out his AD or not? And if, 23:57 you know, if, if they're not gonna lower athletic fees and they're not going t- and they're gonna persist, at some schools, in making athletics pay out of, out of state tuition fees, 24:13 the AD's hands are really tied. I remember Dave Hart telling me that of the athletic budget, when you took out all of the t- Um, contractual obligations to the university, to coaches, 24:31 to the conference. The AD was only in charge, had discretionary control of about 5% of the budget. Not much. It's not much. And so now you got, 24:47 if you got $100 million athletic budget, you're looking at a 22%, and I'm only in control of five? Um, I mean, I'd be a, you'd be a hell no to giving Florida State more money, you know? 25:05 Yep. That, that'd be the easiest decision you make that day. And so yeah, there's, there's guys, uh, sitting in an AD chair that are gonna have to say no, 25:19 but if they were sitting in a AD chair where it was a $200 million budget, they might say yes. I mean, it's situational decision-making. So I, I, um, hey, let's go back to the original premise. 25:37 They're having meetings about it. That's progress. You know, this lawsuit is, we say it bears no fruit that we're 10 months into it, but we've already gotten a success initiative out of it, and we're looking at, 25:56 um, the presidents traveling with all the other things they're having to do. They're traveling to have a meeting on this topic. That tells me there's progress. They may not be happy about their travel plans, 26:14 but they're doing it. And, uh, so yeah, we'll see where it goes. But it, it is encouraging. Yeah, it's interesting. 26:25 I mean, you could say leverage, you know, the, the lawsuit is being used as leverage by Florida State and Clemson- 100%... to, "Hey, we're having a conversation because of, of the lawsuit." 26:35 And, and it took a lot of money to get there, probably millions of dollars- Mm-hmm... of, of legal fees across the board when you look at 26:43 a lot of Florida State lawyers outside of the general counsel, a lot of Clemson lawyers outside of their general counsel. Um, a lot of flying back and forth. 26:51 But it, it has got- gotten to a point where, uh, again, where we all started. It's an olive branch. I have no clue how strong it is. I have more questions than, than probably answers. But- Yeah... 27:03 but the curiosity, uh, the curiosity is, is definitely there for what could become of this. Yes, very much. Um, but it's, it's, uh, when we first started this in December of '22, when Florida State and 27:22 the ACC filed lawsuits against each other, every legal expert I knew said, "This'll never get to discovery." You know, "This'll never go to trial. This is all, you know, a leverage play to 27:41 get to a settlement that you weren't able to get to without filing a lawsuit." And so, I don't know, it sure looks that like those guys were right, you know, that this is a step. And, uh- It is a step. 27:58 I think this is an interesting question, and, and one that was kind of on my mind because it's on the mind of a lot of national writers as they're, um, they're, they're definitely taking shots at Florida State being 0-3, 0-3, and through the lens of this lawsuit. 28:14 Uh, Kelly Lowry, former Florida State quarterback, we thank you for watching as always and, and offering your thoughts. Kelly's asking, "Does Florida State lose leverage at 0-3?" 28:27 I, I have a, a short answer, but, but Jerry, how about your thoughts? No, no, I want you... I want to hear your answer. I'm curious. 28:34 I, I, I don't think the football record, it matters a lot in the big scheme of perspective and how you are viewed as a brand. I'm not discounting that. I'm not sure one and two or 0-3 mean very much as far as 28:52 people are sitting down at a table and discussing the potential of financially what, what does this revenue restructure look like. Yeah. I, I was gonna say a similar thing. 29:06 When the chart Alford showed, the years that he, he was, you know, showing, uh, included a lot of not successful years for Florida State, you know. If you look back the last 10 years, 29:22 you know, the third team we were great, but in between there were some lean years. 29:30 Uh, and the second thing, I think Florida State is one of those brands, it has a, a large following of Seminoles that are very loyal to the brand, 29:41 and then it has a bunch of people that wear, usually they wear the color orange, and they're gonna tune in hoping to see us get beat. You, you know? The Dallas Cowboy effect. It's America's team. Love 'em or hate 'em. 29:57 And, uh, I think there's probably a lot of people tuning in because they want to see us get smacked, and, and a lot of SEC fans and our, our arch rivals. But 30:12 I, I, I tried to look at the television numbers to see how we were doing, and I, I didn't... I, what... I got distracted from it, but I, I wonder with our losses how our numbers are. 30:29 You know, I think the ratings for Georgia Tech game, obviously a week zero game, is an outlier when you're looking at ratings. Right. But those ratings were really good. I think it was well past four million. 30:38 Saw that one. Um, I haven't honestly looked at the last two. Who knows what Cal's gonna bring to the table. 30:45 Uh, the, the, the joke about SMU is that SMU is not a great ratings type of team, but, but Florida State's gonna play there next week. Um, I, I will be very curious just to see what these ratings numbers look like. 30:59 Jerry, we have a little bit more to discuss. We wanna talk, um, Tennessee's going to have a talent tax. Oh. Of course, they had a board of trustees meeting last week. Stick around for this. [coughs] Yeah. 31:10 There's some interesting discussions here. 31:12 We're, we're wrapping up what we're talking about as far as this, uh, revenue structure proposal, but we got a few more business of college athletics topics to discuss on the other side of this break, so stick with us. 31:21 [waves crashing] The Back Shore, that stretch of fluffy sand just beyond the reach of the salty waves. The place reserved for volleyball nets, cookouts, and the air filled with fun and laughter. 31:35 Celebrate The Back Shore with Back Shore Apparel. Grab an amazingly soft and comfy Back Shore Apparel beach hoodie to keep you protected from the sun's harmful rays. 31:43 Or the Back Shore revamped trucker hat, a modern twist on a classic favorite. Crafted from moisture-wicking fabrics, ensuring they're lightweight and breathable, not to mention durable with their unique floating feature. 31:55 Shop now at backshoreapparel.com. And right now FSU fans get 10% off your order with code FSU10. [upbeat music] Hey, Seminole fans. 32:06 Alumni Hall is your ultimate FSU shopping experience, and has moved to a new location off Timberlane Road in Tallahassee. Shop FSU gear from Nike, Champion, New Era, Yeti, and more. 32:16 Alumni Hall has Seminole gear for the entire family, plus accessories and gifts. Spend $150 and you'll earn $10 off your next purchase with their Hall Pass rewards. 32:26 Stop by their new location on Timberlane Road near REI, or shop anytime online at alumnihall.com. Alumni Hall, where Seminole fans shop. Finding an experienced lawyer you can trust is crucial. 32:39 With over 50 years of combined litigation experience, the attorneys at Mowry Law Firm are dedicated to providing our clients with exceptional legal services. 32:47 Focusing on car and trucking accidents, premises liability, and wrongful death. Call 904-824-7799. Mowrylaw.com. All right, we're back on the Osceola Seminole Sidelines. Hope you're having a good Wednesday. 33:01 We're gonna continue some of our, uh, business of college athletics discussions. Um, I, I want to get into the board of trustees notes later on, but, but this one is absolutely fascinating, I think to both of us. 33:17 Tennessee announced on Tuesday, in the middle of an incredible start, what they've had beating NC State. I believe they're 3-0, and it's not even close. 33:26 Uh, Tennessee looking every bit of, of a top 10 team, a likely college football playoff team. They next year will have a 10% talent tax for every season ticket holder to purchase. 33:40 Tennessee's got a massive, rabid fan base. Um, never been ne- to Neyland Stadium myself, but hear it's an incredible experience. Jerry, your thoughts on Tennessee doing this 10% tal- talent tax. 33:56 Why are they doing it, and, and do you think that will be successful? Uh, okay. The, the... W- well, I first of all, let me say, when I first heard this $22.5 million, um, 34:13 f- revenue sharing law was passed, or not passed, it was a settlement. It would've been far worse had the NCAA and the, uh, conferences not agreed to this settlement. 34:28 You know, the S- the Supreme Court would've, uh, ruled in favor of the plaintiff. Uh, any antitrust case that comes before the Supreme Court, the NCAA will lose. Last time it was 9 to 0. 34:46 Um, so they, they rushed to, you know, "Let's, we better settle this," and they did. Uh, so each school is gonna be about 22 and a half million. Where's the money gonna come from? 35:02 You know, if you think about it, Seminole Boosters is raising a- about that much a year that they transfer to athletics, and we're getting donor fatigue just from that alone. Right. Um, 35:17 so you gonna go out and raise twice as much? [phone dings] Unlikely. Where else do you come up with $22.5 million? Well, you know- That's-... one, uh, tickets. You know, generally you go to tickets, ticket sales. 35:33 And if you can't sell more, you've got to either put in more premium seating, you know, that you can charge more for, or you just put a tax on the seats across the board. Raise your... 35:48 I mean, every time I, when I ran ticket priority policies, we did three ticket... You know, I was in charge of it, 35:58 and Andy said the, the athletic board said, "We gotta change the ticket priority policy, 'cause we need to raise an extra $6 million." Um, you know, that's how you do it. And, uh, 36:16 and so I knew there was gonna be an athletic director that was gonna come out and say, "Well, let's just put a tax on tickets." And I think, I think you'll find a lot of athletic departments are gonna do this. 36:31 So I know the fans listening to this are going, they're grabbing their wallets as I speak. But y- ADs don't have a lot of choices. Like I said, Dave Hart said 5% of his budget was discretionary. Um, 36:50 you can cut, you can cut your budget, but it's hard to cut 22 million out of your budget, you know? Especially when the coaches' salaries are contractual. Exactly. 37:07 So man, I, I knew this was coming. And I, in a way I applaud the Tennessee athletic director for being transparent and calling it a, a talent tax. 37:26 But I don't know how many fans are really gonna appreciate that. I was gonna say, I think that's a fan calling saying, "Jerry, that's a lot of money." [laughs] I mean, it... 37:34 Oh, yeah, you're gonna get a phone call, promise you. [laughs] If you're, if you're buying... And in Tennessee their tickets are a lot more expensive than at Florida State. 37:44 But think about a family who has six tickets on the east side of Dove Campbell Stadium, and they're paying $350 a ticket. It's 2,100 bucks. So you're looking at another $210. 38:02 Right. And then your quarterback goes out there and doesn't play a very good game. Do you get a refund on that $210, that ta- that talent tax? I think, I think calling it a talent tax, um, 38:20 puts the players in the crosshairs of the boos. Because, you know, the guys who are paying NIL money and, and not seeing a good performance from the players they're funding through their NIL, 38:37 uh, aren't happy. But there aren't many of those people in your s- in your stadium. Now what you're doing is you're putting all 100,000 of their season ticket holders have some skin in the game 38:53 by calling it a talent tax. I'm not sure they've done that. And it elevates expectations. Huh? It elevates the expectations. It, it elevates the expectation. I like, I like it that everybody's got some skin in the game, 39:08 but, but you're really, uh... You've got a professionalized situation already with NIL. And I heard a number of people sitting around me in the Champions Club booing 39:24 who s- who told me, "You know, I've never booed a player in my life, but now they're getting paid." You know, they're not amateurs anymore, and so they feel empowered that they can boo them. 39:38 And so I don't know, man, I think that's, uh, that's a little bit of a risky deal. I like it because it's transparent, but I'm not sure the AD shouldn't have just manned up and, and said, "Hey, 39:56 I got to generate 22 and a half million, and I'm coming, come to you for 10 of it. And that's what it... You know, we're going to charge everybody 10% more on their season tickets, 40:09 and, and that's going to pay half of this 20 million that a mandated federal court has put on me." You know? I think people might swallow that pill a little easier, but I, I'm not sure. 40:25 And I ask our, our listeners, you know, please let us know. You know, chime into this call or email us. I'd be curious. It might be a good poll for us to run on our message board. Sure. 40:38 If, if the, if the athletic director really needed this, which they do, which would you rather have? W- just increase season... Uh, uh, and oh, by the way, not only is Tennessee 40:57 increasing 10% for a talent tax, but they're also increasing their season ticket price by 4.5%, uh, as a matter of annual business. 41:11 Um, by the way, twi- uh, inflation is down, d- now down to 2.5%, and, and they're, there's... They got inflation of 4.5% on their tickets. Even with getting an extra 40 million from ESPN. 41:31 I don't know, man. It- It would s- it would not sit easy with me if I was a Tennessee fan. Now let me tell you why that's... They can do it. They have 103,000 seat stadium, and it's been sold out for years. Right. 41:47 They got a winning team, and they have a waiting list of 15,000 season ticket holders. So if you don't like this talent tax, there's, there, there's a guy on the waiting list that will be just fine with it. 42:04 And so they're in a, they're in a very bull market. And you can do a lot of things when you're in a bull market that we can't do here at Florida State, where we got a million and a half people within a three-hour drive. 42:25 You know, we, we'd piss them off [laughs] by doing a lot less than this, and, uh, uh, we have a s- much softer market than, uh, than they got up there in Knoxville. Right. 42:40 I mean, again, again, there's not as many people near Tallahassee within a three-hour drive because a lot of it's- Yeah... pine trees and, and fish. It's, it's just not- It also makes money. Yeah... 42:50 yeah, it, it, it's a tough one. So, um, I thought it was very interesting that it's an athletic director at a Power Two school that is coming out first and doing this. I mean, honestly, if you are, 43:04 let's say, a, a Big 12 athletic director and you're doing it, I think it's very, very understandable the why, because you've got a revenue gap by comparison to an SEC or Big Ten. 43:16 But I, I think we're dealing with a lot of the, um, the, the worst o- of, of the okay or, or bad options. 43:25 It's, it's something that a lot of ADs are discussing and trying to figure out, "Okay, what do you think we can actually get away with?" Because the bill's gonna come due here pretty soon, August of 2025. Oh, yeah. 43:38 Lots of questions. And that's why he's... That, well, that's why he's doing it now. Because you've gotta print your ticket applications and put them in the mail with a February deadline to get the revenue- Right... 43:53 to pay September '25. [laughs] Yeah. It's, um- I mean, if Alford doesn't do it, if Alford's not thinking or doing it, which he's probably not, um, I'm sure he's gonna do something else. 44:09 But if you wanna see some tickets to help bail you out, you have to make that decision today. Absolutely. Absolutely. 44:24 Well, let's, let's dive into some of these, uh, Florida State Board of Trustees notes because a lot of it applies to athletics, and I'm kinda curious, uh, Jerry, for some of your thoughts. I, I think 44:35 these, these are kinda nuggets that, that readers don't wanna miss because there, there's a lot that comes out of these meetings. They're very long and sometimes not geared toward athletics. 44:46 But a, a lot of discussion, you know, Michael Alford mentioned they've got a, a working group to discuss, uh, the roster limits. Again, the roster limits, that's coming out of, uh, this house NCAA case. 44:58 Um, FSU baseball could go up to 34 scholarships. That's going to be, um, potentially for the 2026 season for, uh, for all NCAA schools. 45:09 So that's, that's an interesting question of how many scholarships might Florida State go up to i- in baseball. Um, still a, a discussion point. They're looking at, uh, you know, formed a committee to evaluate that. 45:23 Why is this important? Link Jaracz is gonna want as many scholarships available as possible because he rec- he's recruiting against not just Eric Bakich at Clemson, but Sully at Florida, and LSU, and other schools. 45:39 You have to have scholarship power. Gone are the days of 11.7 scholarships. Gone are the days for, for college softball, um, where I, I think it was in the neighborhood of 13 or 14 scholarships. 45:51 I'm, I'm not exactly sure. But these can still be equivalency scholarships again, 45:58 but these are significant decisions as far as having the recruiting power to retain some talent, having the, the power to attract some talent. 46:10 I don't know where we're gonna land in terms of the number of scholarships, but Florida State's been, been very proactive here. 46:18 Again, Michael Alford, a, a college baseball player, he's running some numbers as well as with the Florida State, um, Florida State staff. 46:25 Uh, Jerry, we've, we talked a little bit about each scholarship could be in the neighborhood of, say, $50,000. This is a significant number. 46:35 If you go from 11.7 to the neighborhood of 34, just, just do the math real quick, I mean, 20 scholarships is, is roughly a million, and this all depends on if you're in state or out of state, right? Right. 46:48 Uh, different numbers. But it, it's, it's another ask for, uh, for the boosters, potentially for ticket holders. Uh, you've gotta come up with that number. 46:59 Um, Jerry, I'm just curious, a- a- as they're looking at baseball, softball, other sports, um, these aren't easy to generate revenue sports [laughs]. 47:10 But how do, how do you look at, um, at finding revenue here to cover these new scholarships? Well, we, in our interview with Michael Alford, he indicated that, uh, if you were to go ahead and fully fund all of them, 47:28 that would be take football from 85 to 105. If you're to take baseball from 11.7 to 34, and softball to I think it's 34 or 35 in softball. 47:44 If you, if you were to do that, bring them all the way up to the t- maximum, it would increase your athletic budget, scholarship budget by about 5 million a year on top of the other stuff. 47:58 So, you know, a total impact on your budget because of the house settlement of 30 million a year. So it's a lot. And, um, how do you go about it? Um, 48:16 you know, you gotta look at everything. Um, you know, like I, I wrote once a while back, you gotta beg, borrow, and steal. 48:27 You know, you gotta beg from your donors and ask them, "If you care about baseball, we wanna increase scholarships by a million a year. Would you be willing to donate to help us do that?" 48:42 You know, would you be willing to pay more for your season tickets either through a t- a tax, [laughs] a scholarship tax, or through, um, maybe a higher, 48:58 you know, a priority policy change? So you, you look at those things. What can we cut out of our baseball budget? You know, so, you know, it's beg. You know, 49:14 you can borrow money to do this in the short term, and you can steal money from the budgets. So you either cut your baseball budget, 49:26 or you look across the athletic department and find where you can steal money out of those budgets. You know, cut, cut unnecessary spending. And, you know, do you have any waste in your department that, 49:44 you know, you can cut? And I, I think what you're gonna see is people will lose jobs. You know, there'll be things that, um, the athletic department will cut out. They're not gonna need people to do it anymore. 50:00 I remember there were budget cuts made while I was there, where they cut the, the maintenance budget. You know, we used to have a, a reserve fund for, uh, for facilities 50:15 and, uh, and during one athletic administration, within about three years, there was no reserve fund left because they were s- you know, I, I use the word steal. They weren't stealing. 50:28 I mean, there's no crime here, but, you know, they would take money out of that budget, you know, rob from Peter to pay Paul and, uh, and, and maintain a balanced athletic budget. 50:41 So Bob, that's what they're gonna have to do, and as you and I were talking to Alford, you know, we asked the question, uh, does this mean you'll renegotiate coaches' salaries? 50:55 And he, he reminded us, "Well, you know, they're contractual to begin with." And then the second thing he said was, "Yes, everything's on the table," and that coaches want to win, and 51:12 a good coach who's a good partner with the athletic director is gonna be willing to negotiate to get to what he believes the number he needs to win, 51:26 and that might be maybe not taking a, a trip, an away trip that, to a tournament. It may be, uh, cutting his staff a little bit. In football, I think that could be a... We might begin to see that. Alford made the point, 51:45 uh, you know, the pendulum has swung with revenue sharing. It used to be the coaches got all the money. If you had a surplus in your budget and a coach wanted a raise, or he was going to Texas A&M, you know, 52:03 you go, "Well, how much do we have to pay him to keep him?" Right? Right. Those days are gonna be gone now. I think you're gonna see, um, coaches' salaries, um, in a lot of sports won't be 52:20 w- you know, they, they won't be going in the direction they have been. You'll start to see a tapering of what coaches are gonna make because you're, you've got a revenue share. 52:32 Staff sizes, I think you'll see a reduction. Some coaches will say, "I don't need all these people." You know? Right. We, um... They're not gonna want to cut their recruiting budgets anymore than they have to. 52:46 Um, and then, uh, facilities. You saw what Ole Miss did, and this was something Andy Miller was preaching many years ago, is, you know, 53:01 you know, think twice before you commit to build a building with a 30-year mortgage and with, you know, half a million to a million dollars in annual maintenance costs on it, you know? And that's what Ole Miss did. 53:16 They s- you know, they said they, they, they, uh, canceled all building projects and, uh, they're putting the money into their NIL and into, a- and into this. 53:33 Um, you know, Florida State's too far down the line on the football operations building now. That, that ship has sailed. But I think you'll see, um, 53:47 c- you know, construction projects are probably gonna slow in college athletics until they can absorb the cost of revenue sharing. 53:58 So instead of the money going to the players and brick and mor- I mean, to the coaches and brick and mortar, it's gonna start swinging to the players, 54:09 whether it be these additional scholarships or whether it be towards revenue sharing and an- and NIL. I agree. Right? That's all you can do: beg, borrow or steal. I don't know any other way. 54:26 Um, now they can, you know, with the new football ops building, that's an expense, right? The new football stadium project is a solution because you can generate more money 54:44 in that- In that facility than you could in the old facility. So you pay the bond issue with it, and it gives you a little surplus you can put towards, um, this. 54:59 As well as it gives you a, a facility that you can activate more than seven days a year. And that's been a dream of mine to see, uh, the football stadium be activated more, 55:17 um, which they do at, at stadiums across the country. But this stadium had some deficiencies that they've addressed in the renovation, uh, to where it, it'll be easier to have concerts and other, other events. 55:34 So they offered expects to be able to generate revenue, um, as a result of this renovation. 55:45 Yeah, I think those are some interesting storylines as you watch down the road to see how, how creative Florida State Athletics gets. 55:51 Uh, as you've mentioned, the Champions Club designed, uh, to be a, a natural amphitheater. So, um, so acoustically, there are some options there for, uh, for bands. 56:03 Hey, as, as we wrap up here on Wednesday, uh, again, if you want more of those FSU Board of Trustees notes, go to the Osceola Village, floridastate.rivals.com. Check us out on the Osceola Village. 56:13 If you're not a subscriber, jump in. It's a good time to, uh, to get all of our notes on not just the football team, but recruiting and, um, and these business of college athletic stories. 56:23 Let's just briefly talk Florida State football and Cal. Yeah. I know we've done a lot of shows Monday, Tuesday. The guys will be back on Thursday. 56:32 Um, I'll, I'll set up the question this way, 'cause I, I think it might be an interesting discussion point for you and me and, and the people watching. 56:41 If I can give you Darius Washington starting at left tackle, again, he was not able to go last week. Something happened in pregame warmups. That helps you a little bit on your offensive line, right? Right. 56:55 But if I give you Jerry Darius Washington back, you can have any one personnel change that you wish on offense. Now, obviously, a lot of people are gonna be screaming for one in particular. Yeah. But I'm, I'm curious. 57:10 You can have one change. What would you do? Well, I think I'd give him Barabbas. You know? I mean, I think the fans are screaming for a change at quarterback, 57:26 and I, I'm not in disagreement with them. Uh, you know, I think, uh, DJ struggled. Well, I don't want to say DJ struggling. The whole offense is struggling. And, uh, and often, and, 57:45 and, uh, I don't think DJ's doing anything to help it. Um, I think you need a spark there. And my, I'm... What I'm saying is football's not rocket science, right? I mean, it... And so that would be the one short answer. 58:06 I'm with you. I think if you stabilize the offensive line, and, and Darius could be a huge part of it. We could see Andre Otto and some capability. 58:16 Um, he's a guy that we think is really, really, if not close to ready, um, ready, ready. Right? Yeah. I, I think the Brock Glenn dynamic gives you an athletic 58:28 quarterback, a guy who, um, processes a little bit faster clearly than, than DJ, a guy who's holding onto the ball a little bit too long. Um, I would go Brock Glenn. 58:40 I would be curious what Andre Otto looks like as my, uh, distant number two request, uh, obviously there. I don't know. I, I was talking about this with the guys on, maybe it was Monday night. 58:51 I don't know if this offense can line up two tight ends, 12 personnel, and just say, "We're gonna out-physical you off the ball in the ground game." I would be curious what it looks like. Brock Glenn is your quarterback. 59:06 You spread people out, three receivers. You try to run with just a very, 59:12 not Jordan Travis type of look from prior years, but you've got that athletic runner, a guy who is going to look to pass if he has the capability to do so. Can it sustain some drives? Can it look better? 59:26 Not saying it's gonna win ball games, but it could look a lot better. Um, that's my argument, I think, for Brock Glenn. I think we've both- Yeah... we're both very curious if that does happen. 59:36 Yeah, I, I, I agree with you. I mean, I think what Brock gives you is partly it's that he's been in the system longer, but he, he's, uh, he processes, uh, the progressions quicker. 59:52 He doesn't hold it as long. He's got a quicker internal clock to get out of there and run, and he, he's a, he's a quicker, more athletic quarterback, 1:00:07 um, in the traditional sense, um, th- that I think can extend some plays. Uh, the other thing about, about this, and I hope everybody that hears this believes me when I say this. I mean, DJ is a 1:00:26 good person from what we can tell. His teammates, uh, seem to like him. There's not any, uh, there's not, there's no reason to fire him o- over the relationship with the players. I mean, don't get me wrong on that point. 1:00:44 I think he's s- good, solid guy. He's quiet. He's a quiet guy. And we've had very successful quarterbacks who are quiet. Charlie Ward. But Charlie was loud with his, the plays he made, 1:01:02 you know? Mm-hmm. And he was inspirational with his actions. Because this offense isn't able to do much, DJ hasn't made plays that spark his teammates. You know? 1:01:19 He, his actions haven't been able to speak. They've been muted by an offense that isn't having success, and that's a shame. I mean, I think if he'd have come out and that first drive we had, man, 1:01:34 ag- uh, there in Dublin, I'm thinking, "Wow." You know? I remember seeing a drive like that with Jameis. [laughs] Remember at Pittsburgh? Yeah, 2015 opener. Wow. 1:01:45 I mean, they're gonna fall in love with DJ if they keep doing this. But that didn't happen, and I, I... He's not the kind of guy that's gonna shake his fist in the air and rally people. Um, 1:02:01 that's, I don't think that's in his nature. Um, I think it's a little more in Brock's nature. I think Brock's the kind of guy, if he... I, I'm thinking about that run where DJ tried to hurdle the guy and 1:02:17 he didn't make it, and he stopped. He didn't keep, he didn't have that second effort to get the first down. I think Brock gets that first down, and I think he comes up shaking his fist and, you know, 1:02:34 the players respond. It's a rallying cry. Yeah. That, and listen, I'm dreaming here. I'm making this stuff up, but you know, that's what my imagination tells me. Um, why? Because we see some of it, you know? 1:02:51 You see a little of that. Um, um, but again, let me j- say... I mean, we said, I said it today. I think for Brock to win this job, he's got to show 1:03:07 his coaches and his teammates that he's clearly the answer, and I haven't seen that. You know? I've, I've seen, I see things he does better, but maybe he's a gamer, you know? 1:03:24 Maybe you need to get him in the game and see what he does, and see how his teammates respond to him. And you know, if, if it's not working, put DJ back in there. But 1:03:36 you know, now Kelly is, Kelly might chime in here, because Kelly and I have had this conversation. You can't do that to a quarterback. You can't put him in for a series, and if it doesn't work out, yank him. 1:03:48 You gotta really give him the game. You gotta commit to him. And whether that's at halftime or it's the whole week of preparation, it's ideal so that, um, you know, he and his teammates can get in sync. 1:04:08 Uh, just throwing him out there is kind of, you're not giving yourself or him the best chance of success, I don't think. But any rate, we'll, we'll see. I don't think Mike is gonna tell us on a Monday, though. Right. 1:04:23 I think a lot of people saw no depth chart changes and took that to be literally what it was going to look like moving forward. Um, I, I think there c- I, I'm not saying there could be some surprises. 1:04:35 I don't think what Mike Norvell puts out on the depth chart on Monday, there's a direct line to what it's gonna look like Saturday night at 7:00 PM against Cal. Um, I, I'll be very curious to see what, what develops, and 1:04:49 if something goes sideways early, do the coaches say, "Hey, let's give Brock a drive or two. Let's see what it looks like"? Um, there are a lot of questions. 1:04:59 I, again, this is a bridge quarterback that's not functioning through three games. Um, the only way I feel you can develop a guy like Brock Glenn is to get him playing time in games. Um, I'm arguing for him to play. 1:05:14 I can definitely argue for him to start, but he needs on-field time, I think is, is where- Yeah... a lot of us are as far as, uh, what his development looks like. Well, I'm gonna, if- Well-... 1:05:25 with Kelly's permission, let me say this. You know, um, in ta- talking to Kelly, you know, you, you can develop... You don't have to be in a game to develop. 1:05:36 You know, if you're going up against a good defense at practice, you're, you're getting better. Um, and yes, once you get into a game, you can develop further. But Brock's a f- what, a red shirt freshman? Right. 1:05:54 And so in most schools he'd be still, you know, going against, you know, his, his own teammates every day at practice. So, a- and the other thing, Bob, I think to be fair, uh, 1:06:11 if Mike were to decide to put Brock in there, it wouldn't be like he was, this is the first time he's practiced with the ones. We see that every day at practice. I mean, there's... 1:06:27 You know, he takes a series with the ones. He takes a series with the twos. Um, Brock has had, you know, plenty of reps with the ones. So I don't think it would be a shock to anybody to see him with the ones in a game. 1:06:45 I mean, I think he's comfortable with them. They're comfortable with him. Would you agree with that? Agree. I agree. So- Yeah. All right. I think we're gonna leave it there for our Wednesday show. 1:06:59 Again, if you missed some of our early discussion about, uh, Ross Dellinger from Yahoo's story about this, uh, revenue restructuring, you can check us out back at the start of the episode. Watch it. 1:07:11 Go back on, uh, Apple Podcasts or Spotify to listen to it. We'll, uh, we'll put the links out there again to, uh, to Ross's story. It's a, it's a must read. 1:07:20 If you're really curious and don't wanna get too deep into the weeds of every movement, that's fine, but this is a pretty significant development there. But again, thanks for watching the Osceola Seminole Sidelines. 1:07:31 If you check us out on Osceola YouTube, Facebook, uh, Pat's Twitter, Kurt's Twitter, they'll be back Thursday, 3:00 PM. Check us out. More of Florida State-Cal. But for now, Jerry Cutts, I'm Bob Ferrante. 1:07:43 Thanks for watching. Take care, and we'll see you soon.