Florida State’s early exit from the ACC Tournament now opens the door to the big-picture questions as the team prepares for the NCAA Tournament.
With a chance to elevate the resume in Charlotte, N.C., FSU squandered the opportunity with four errors, a passed ball, 14 strikeouts and 12 runners left on base in an 8-6 loss to Pittsburgh on Friday. It was one of the worst defensive nights for the Seminoles in 2026, albeit on a slick field that played fast with frequent rain.
FSU (39-16) needed a win over Pittsburgh, a team it swept in Tallahassee on May 1-3, to earn a shot at North Carolina in the semifinals. Facing the Tar Heels, win or lose, would have given the Seminoles a much-needed RPI bump.
UCLA, Georgia Tech, North Carolina, Georgia and Texas are viewed as national seeds. D1baseball’s Kendall Rogers wrote that he thinks FSU is among six teams pushing for three top-8 national seeds (Alabama, Auburn, Texas A&M, Florida and Southern Miss are the other five). D1baseball projects FSU as a No. 10 seed going into Saturday’s conference tournament games.
Baseball America also views FSU as the No. 10 seed, with five SEC schools earning top-8 seeds (Georgia, Texas, Auburn, Alabama and Florida). The site has FSU facing Alabama in the Supers if both teams advance.
As the NCAA Selection Committee watches conference tournaments, led by FSU athletics director Michael Alford, they will have to weigh teams. Texas and Alabama each enjoyed a double bye in the SEC Tournament as a top-4 seed but lost their quarterfinal games. Florida has already defeated Vanderbilt and Alabama, with a matchup against Georgia to come in one semifinal on Saturday (Auburn and Arkansas are in the other semifinal).
The 16 regional host teams will be announced on Sunday night. There’s no doubt that FSU will be among the top 16. But the questions: Are the Seminoles a top-8 seed? If not, who would they be paired up against? These are big considering FSU was 27-4 at Dick Howser Stadium this season.
Let’s look at FSU’s resume:
Best series wins: The Seminoles have won three series against teams viewed as No. 2 seeds in the regionals. FSU swept Wake Forest in mid-March on the road while also winning series at Virginia and against Miami at Howser. There’s also a series win over NC State, projected as a No. 3 seed. The Seminoles won eight ACC series, including all five at home.
Worst series losses: FSU was swept at Georgia Tech and Stanford. The Yellow Jackets are a slam dunk pick for a top-8 national seed, so there’s not much harm there. But the Cardinal’s sweep is a tough one for FSU as Stanford’s RPI is 100.
Neutral-site games: While not a series, FSU lost to RPI No. 3 Auburn and RPI No. 9 Nebraska in February in Arlington, Texas. FSU’s win over No. 53 Michigan was the other game that weekend.
About those midweeks: FSU suffered a season sweep to Florida. The Seminoles won all of their other Tuesday/Wednesday games. There’s a feeling that midweeks aren’t that important in the big picture for the NCAA Selection Committee.
FSU’s strength: The team was built around pitching and Myles Bailey as the cornerstone of the lineup. Wes Mendes (9-3, 2.93 ERA) delivered a consistent season and was the ACC’s pitcher of the year. Even in FSU’s loss to Pitt, he battled through the errors and a passed ball to give FSU a chance.
Mendes and Bryson Moore were among the top 10 ACC pitchers in opponents’ batting average (.209 for Mendes and .221 for Moore). Trey Beard was 17th at .243. We’ve said it all year: Despite the struggles around them in the field and inconsistencies in the lineup, FSU had a chance to win any weekend series because of its pitching.
John Abraham and Chris Knier have been dependable bullpen arms. Some relievers have struggled, but FSU’s 4.07 ERA is second in the ACC.
FSU’s weakness: Without Bailey, the Seminoles have been inconsistent at the plate. There are too many strikeouts and often too many runners left on base. FSU’s .282 batting average (11th in ACC), .385 on-base percentage (14th) and 72 home runs (13th) don’t stack up all that well compared to other lineups of top teams around the nation let alone the league.
Hunter Carns leads FSU with a .311 batting average (54th in ACC), while Brayden Dowd had 10 home runs (35th). It was going to be an uphill battle without Bailey and Jarrett tried various lineups with mixed results. John Stuetzer impressed as a freshman and Brody DeLamielleure was a red-hot hitter in April and May. But the lineup top to bottom wasn’t good enough. The infield also was an adventure. Jarrett turned to Ben Barrett two weeks ago to play first base and be a spark in the lineup.
Osceola’s conclusion: It felt like FSU had some work to do in Charlotte, N.C., and fell short. While the Seminoles have eight series wins and should be praised for how they battled after Bailey’s injury, their resume doesn’t stack up as well against other teams — especially those from the SEC. It would be a bitter scenario for FSU, but has Florida’s performance in the SEC Tournament helped the Gators overcome a checkered resume and earn a top-8 national seed?
A year ago, FSU won its regional but had to travel to face Oregon State in the Super Regional. Fans can hope FSU doesn’t have to travel that far for a Super Regional, but the Seminoles could be paired up with an SEC school in the best-of-three series (if they advance out of the regional).
Thanks for reading the Osceola. Subscribe now for 40 percent off to enjoy a full year of coverage of FSU athletics. You’ll also earn a $15 gift card at the Osceola’s merch store.
